| 2007-08 | Marqus Blakely, Vermont
| | 2006-07 | Jamar Wilson, Albany | | 2005-06 | Jamar Wilson, Albany | | 2004-05 | Taylor Coppenrath, Vermont | | 2003-04 | Taylor Coppenrath, Vermont | | 2002-03 | Taylor Coppenrath, Vermont | | 2001-02 | T.J. Sorrentine, Vermont | | 2000-01 | Norman Richardson, Hofstra | | 1999-00 | Craig Claxton, Hofstra | | 1998-99 | Mike Pegues, Delaware | | 1997-98 | Craig Claxton, Hofstra | | 1996-97 | Tonji Awojobi, Boston University | | 1995-96 | Malik Rose, Drexel | | 1994-95 | Malik Rose, Drexel | | 1993-94 | Scott Drapeau, New Hampshire | | 1992-93 | Vin Baker, Hartford | | 1991-92 | Kevin Roberson, Vermont | | 1990-91 | Matt Johnson, Vermont | | 1989-90 | Steven Key, Boston University | | 1988-89 | Jeff Robinson, Siena | | 1987-88 | Larry Jones, Boston University | | 1986-87 | Reggie Lewis, Northeastern | | 1985-86 | Reggie Lewis, Northeastern | | 1984-85 | Reggie Lewis, Northeastern | | 1983-84 | Mark Halsel, Northeastern | | 1982-83 | Jeff Cross, Maine | | 1981-82 | Perry Moss, Northeastern | | 1980-81 | Mike Ferrara, Colgate | | 1979-80 | Rufus Harris, Maine/Ron Perry, Holy Cross |
|